Writing a critical journal review

Critical review writing asks you to evaluate and summarize a given text. It would be of a chapter, book or a journal article. Writing critical reviews needs you to read the text in detail and the other related texts to enable you present a reasonable and fair evaluation of the text. Below are some tips on how to write a critical evaluation essay:

Writing a critical journal review

You are expected to read the article carefully, analyse it, and evaluate the quality and originality of the research, as well as its relevance and presentation. Its strengths and weaknesses are assessed, followed by its overall value.

writing a critical journal review

Do not be confused by the term critique: You should address both the positive and negative aspects. If not, the following steps may help you. These steps are based on a detailed description of how to analyse and evaluate a research article provided by Wood in her lab guide.

The minnesota review: a journal of creative and critical writing | Duke University Press

This guide is divided into two parts. The second part, "Writing your Critique," discusses two possible ways to structure your critique paper.

Researching the Critique The questions listed under many of the subheadings in this section may provide you with a good place to begin understanding what you are looking for and what form your critique might take.

Review articles summarize and evaluate current studies research articles on a particular topic.

writing a critical journal review

Select a review article on a topic that interests you and that is written clearly so you can understand it. Select a Research Article Use the review article to select a research article.

This can be very useful in writing your critique. Analyse the Text Read the article s carefully. As you read the article s use the following questions to help you understand how and why the research was carried out.

What is the author's central purpose? What methods were used to accomplish this purpose systematic recording of observations, analysis and evaluation of published research, assessment of theory? What were the techniques used? What kind of data can be obtained using each technique?

How are such data interpreted? What kind of information is produced by using the technique? What were the results of the study? How was each technique used to obtain each result?

How did each result contribute to answering the question or testing the hypothesis raised in the introduction? How were the results interpreted? Were the author s able to answer the question test the hypothesis raised? Source of questions in each section Wood, 4. Establish the Research Context Once you are reasonably familiar with the article, it is important to gain an understanding of the research context, both societal and intellectual.

To establish the research context, questions such as the following should be addressed: Who conducted the research?The Book Review or Article Critique (Margaret Procter, Writing Support, University of Toronto) Critical Reviews of Journal Articles (Herbert Coutts, University of Alberta) Writing a Critical Review (The Writing Centre, Queen's University).

You are here

A critical review is not to be mistaken for the literature review. A 'critical review' is a complete type of text, discussing one particular article or book in detail.

The 'literature review', which also needs to be 'critical', is a part of a larger type of text e.g. a chapter of your dissertation. Writing a critical review of an article published in a scholarly journal is a common assignment for students enrolled in a higher education .

A critical review is much more than a simple summary; it is an analysis and evaluation of a book, article, or other medium. Writing a good critical review requires that you understand the material, and that you.

Critical review writing asks you to evaluate and summarize a given text. It would be of a chapter, book or a journal article.

Writing critical reviews needs you to read the text in detail and the other related texts to enable you present a reasonable and fair evaluation of the text.

Writing a Critical Review. A critical review is not to be mistaken for the literature review. A 'critical review' is a complete type of text, discussing one .

How to Write Critical Reviews of Journal Articles | Synonym